Why give a racial joke?

Message Topic Search Topic Options Post Reply Create New Topic Printable Version

I want to start by saying that I think Ms. Peyroux is extremely talented and I enjoy her music.  Yet last night, at the concert in Santa Barbara, she gave a racial joke where the punchline made fun of an Asian accent.  As she was setting up the joke I was thinking "Don't do it", but she did, imitating a Japanese accent, which was followed by laughter (presumably by non-Asians).  

After this, I couldn't really enjoy the show.  She has ceased to be a singer whose music "transcended" languages.  Rather, she became a parochial singer, whose own culture made fun of others.  

I hope she doesn't use that joke again (or any other racial joke) in her future performances.  And although, losing one fan may not affect her all too much, I hope she will change her tune a bit.

sincerely, 
a former fan

Edited by Profjoe

Author	Message Topic Search Topic Options Post Reply Create New Topic Printable Version
Profjoe Members Profile Send Private Message Find Members Posts Add to Buddy List New Member Joined: October 05 2006 Online Status: Offline Posts: 2	Quote Reply Topic: Why give a racial joke? Posted: October 05 2006 at 1:11pm
	I want to start by saying that I think Ms. Peyroux is extremely talented and I enjoy her music. Yet last night, at the concert in Santa Barbara, she gave a racial joke where the punchline made fun of an Asian accent. As she was setting up the joke I was thinking "Don't do it", but she did, imitating a Japanese accent, which was followed by laughter (presumably by non-Asians). After this, I couldn't really enjoy the show. She has ceased to be a singer whose music "transcended" languages. Rather, she became a parochial singer, whose own culture made fun of others. I hope she doesn't use that joke again (or any other racial joke) in her future performances. And although, losing one fan may not affect her all too much, I hope she will change her tune a bit. sincerely, a former fan Edited by Profjoe

Lili Members Profile Send Private Message Find Members Posts Add to Buddy List New Member Joined: October 31 2005 Online Status: Offline Posts: 6	Quote Reply Posted: October 05 2006 at 1:37pm
	I am a big fan of Ms Peyroux's I read this forum from time to time. It is disappointing to be faced with what is interpreted as a racial comment and it is unfortunate that this offended you. I cannot say for certain, but, given Ms Peyroux's background, her own experiences living and working as a street muscian I am sure she has an understanding, more than most, of being different and of many types of biases and discrimination that are faced in this world. From her interviews, her liner notes, the text she has added to her playlist on Itunes I have only gotten the impression that she is an open minded, intelligent and compassionate young woman. This was a poor judgement call on her part. However I am sure that neither offence nor racist slurs were the intent. If Ms.Peyroux had chosen to adopt a different accent a French, a Texan or a British accent. Would we conclude so readily that it was a racist joke I wonder. Perhaps not. Either way she should certainly take more care. I hope she gets to read this, understand the pitfalls of such jokes, and avoid careless commentary in the future. She is too great a performer to risk compromising her performances.

Profjoe Members Profile Send Private Message Find Members Posts Add to Buddy List New Member Joined: October 05 2006 Online Status: Offline Posts: 2	Quote Reply Posted: October 05 2006 at 4:06pm
	Lili, I grant Ms Peyroux the benefit of the doubt. Namely, that she probably didn't intend any offense. Yet, what strikes me as a bit strange is that if she had made a comment about Jews, African-Americans, or the Latin community, no matter what her intentions were, she would have to apologize because it would be offensive. Yet with an Asian joke, we just let that go because she didn't intend to offend anyone? That seems a bit odd and a bit unfair.